Nature as Infrastructure: The Investment Case for Rewilding
Twenty years ago, solar power was a pipedream. Today it’s often the cheapest form of energy and a fixture in ordinary pension portfolios.
Ben Goldsmith, who spent two decades building a green investment platform that grew to nearly £2 billion under management, now leads Nattergal, the company he founded to restore nature across entire landscapes using investor capital that expects infrastructure-like returns. He believes nature is next in line to become a mainstream infrastructure asset.
In conversation with Sanjeev Krishnan and Frédéric Michel, Ben explains why the biggest obstacle to restoring ecosystems isn’t a shortage of projects or money but a shortage of buyers for what healthy ecosystems provide. He describes how England rebuilt farm support after Brexit around “public money for public good,” the new markets for biodiversity credits and pollution mitigation that followed, and what they mean for struggling upland farmers. Ben, a self-described small‑c conservative, argues that nature shouldn’t be a bipartisan issue, pointing to the conservation records of Nixon, Theodore Roosevelt, and Margaret Thatcher, and warns that dragging it into the culture wars serves no one. He also reflects on where his bond with nature began, how it saved him in his darkest moments, and why restoring wild places now feels like his life’s purpose.
Key Takeaways
-
Ben argues that philanthropy and government budgets can’t fund large-scale nature recovery on their own. Nattergal’s goal is to make restoration look like a bridge, toll road, or solar asset to institutional investors, with infrastructure-like, risk-adjusted returns.
-
Ben points to natural flood management, drought resilience, and clean water as the most solid category of natural capital investing. The Evenlode deal shows how railways, cities, utilities, and water companies can all pay for a restored river because each one benefits from slower, cleaner water.
-
Stewardship payments, habitat banks, and flood management schemes give farmers revenue that isn’t tied to food commodity prices. Ben sees these streams as a way to steady a volatile business and keep remote rural communities in place.
-
Ben contends that agricultural and fishing subsidies distort how land and sea are used. He and Sanjeev discuss alternatives, from England’s post-Brexit reforms to a possible role for central banks in valuing natural capital.
-
Ben highlights “insetting,” where companies buy nature-based carbon from projects that also protect their own supply chains. He cites Evian’s restoration of its home landscape and SABMiller’s forest work around Bogotá as early examples.
Transcript
Highlights
- From Green Investing to Nature Recovery
- Can Nature Follow Solar’s Path?
- How Nature Pulled Ben Through His Hardest Time
- Nature as Infrastructure: Restoring the River Evenlode
- How Farm and Fishing Subsidies Reward the Wrong Things
- Why Nature Shouldn’t Be Partisan
- Can the UK Be a Laboratory for Nature Recovery?
Ben Goldsmith: I think that nature should be a kind of non-partisan issue. And when it becomes partisan, I’m highly suspicious of the motivations of those who make it so. So where do I think we are? I think somehow nature has been partially dragged into the culture wars.
But nevertheless, polling shows that people really care and they want nature back.
Tonya Bakritzes: With the midterms behind us, American politics is entering a new chapter, and moments like this open the door to fresh ideas. One place to look is across the Atlantic. In Britain, rail operators, utilities, and developers are starting to pay for restored rivers and habitats because it protects their bottom line. Ben Goldsmith is here to make the case that protecting nature isn’t just good for the planet. It can be a smart investment, with wins for farmers, businesses and communities alike. And it shouldn’t be a partisan issue.
Ben is the founder of Nattergal, an investor-backed company restoring nature on a landscape scale. In this episode, he opens up about how nature pulled him through the hardest time of his life. He explains how farm and fishing subsidies end up rewarding the wrong things, and walks us through real projects where restoring nature pays off.
Ben makes a sound economic case for investing in nature, but also a deeply human one.
Please stay tuned for important disclosures at the end of this episode.
Frédéric Michel: Hello, Ben.
Ben Goldsmith: Hi, Frédéric. Hi, Sanjeev. Thank you very much for having me on the podcast.
Frédéric Michel: Thanks for doing this.
Sanjeev Krishnan: Thanks for doing this.
Frédéric Michel: It’s great to have you, because we want to talk about many, many things. You’re someone who’s the ideal person to cover sustainable investment, agriculture, natural conservation, lots of other things in the UK as well. So I just wanted to start by asking you to talk a bit more, as an introduction. Walk us through your path from investing in energy, which was where you started, energy and resource efficiency, to the work you focus on today.
Ben Goldsmith: My name is Ben Goldsmith, and I’ve been all my life in London, in England, and the surrounding countryside.
And my love has always been, since my earliest recollections, wildlife and nature. I grew up in the green suburbs of West London, in a landscape known as Richmond Park, which is surprisingly wild, by the way, even though it’s technically London. The suburbs on the west of London are really full of wildlife. I was surrounded by woodland and grassland and scrub and interesting birds. And when we visited the real countryside, I had an aunt out in Dorset, and we would sort of pile into a car and drive for hours. I would not find much. I found the actual countryside quite disappointing. These very neatly managed English monochrome green fields and neat, tidy hedges and a few crows and really not much wildlife. I was always keen to get back to digging out ponds and putting up bird boxes, and I knew the names of the wildflowers and so on. So from a very early age, my fascination and love was nature and wildlife.
But I always had an interest in investment. I come from a financial family. My father, the late Sir James Goldsmith, was a big tycoon. He really pioneered the leveraged buyout. And in the 1960s and ’70s, he also built businesses. He built Grand Union supermarkets in the US, Mothercare in the UK, he owned Marmite and Bovril and so on. And he died when I was young. He died of pancreatic cancer when I was 15 years old and left behind a pretty typical endowment-style family investment business. And as the one of his eight children who was most interested in and knowledgeable about finance and investments, I got involved very early on. My first job was in a broking firm called Hargreave Hale, which became kind of called Canaccord Genuity. And I also was chairing my family group from the age of 22. I’m now 45. So I had an interest in commerce and in investment.
But really, my love and the backdrop to my life and the time I spend with my family and my children was all about the outdoors, wildlife, and nature. And so I thought a happy compromise, in terms of a business to build, was to invest in a green way. And we’re talking kind of 2004, ’05, ’06, and I created a venture capital firm called WHEB, W‑H-E‑B.
We raised 25 million pounds to invest in green industries of the future. And suffice to say, there would have been perhaps easier ways to make money in 2005, ’06, ’07 than investing in biodegradable plastics and energy-efficient widgets for manufacturing and so on. But we plowed this furrow for a number of years, and we built quite a large investment business together.
And we grew to assets under management of almost two billion pounds, of which around a quarter was in venture capital and growth equity and small buyouts, with eventually a real emphasis on the German Mittelstand, kind of real businesses manufacturing things rather than brand-new startups. And then a quarter was in infrastructure investing, creating new solar and wind assets and running them, and the rest was in a kind of ESG, relatively bland, long-only equity strategy. So I built a kind of multi-asset platform investing in what you might describe as the green economy or the green industrial revolution. And that was my career for a while, until that business got sold during the course of 2024, ’25.
Frédéric Michel: And then…
Ben Goldsmith: So for the first time in my life, I didn’t really have a day job. And I decided that I really want to focus my life, my commercial and professional life, around nature. I’ve been increasingly involved, in an activist and a political and a philosophical sense, in how to bring about dramatic and much-needed nature recovery in Britain and Europe and beyond.
And so my interest is in establishing the idea of nature as infrastructure, nature as an infrastructure asset class. And this is something that the US is leading on, and the UK is not far behind.
And I founded a business called Nattergal. And the purpose of Nattergal is to restore nature on a landscape scale using investor capital. In other words, capital that requires a decent, infrastructure-like, risk-adjusted return, because that will be a game changer. Since I was a child, I’ve dreamed of making nature bigger, better, more joined up, restoring landscapes, restoring seascapes, restoring missing species, and so on.
And it’s always been something that’s funded through philanthropy. And there is not enough philanthropy out there to do the heavy lifting when it comes to large-scale nature recovery. And governments, as we know, are out of money, and they don’t prioritize nature in any case. And so the best we can expect from governments is better regulation and a reduction in some of the negative incentives that exist around nature, the kind of agricultural subsidies and so on. We’ll talk about that.
So the big game changer will be getting institutional investors to allocate capital to nature recovery, and that’s what Nattergal’s about. And we raised a forty million pound seed round in 2024, and we are now restoring four large landscapes in England, and we have revenues, and we’re showing that this can work.
Sanjeev Krishnan: That’s a phenomenal story, and congratulations on the exit. Despite the reluctancy, it’s great to have that performance. And I guess there is a trend that I’ve seen the last two or three years of really successful investors in energy and infrastructure looking at nature.
Give me the compare and contrast with what you did in sort of infrastructure and energy versus what you’re seeing as the landscape, pardon the pun, in the nature and natural capital side.
Ben Goldsmith: I think there are parallels. I think the most obvious parallel is solar. When we started out, in my early twenties, solar was considered a bit of a pipe dream, or even a joke. My late uncle Teddy, who was a pioneer of the environmental movement, was one of the founders of the Green Party. Not that, by the way, that party would be recognizable to him in its current form. But he was a sort of 1960s, 1970s environmental thinker, and kind of a bit of a hippie.
And his brother, my father, was the kind of industrialist. And the two of them spent the last seven years of my father’s life funding environmental work on a philanthropic basis across Europe. But my uncle Teddy put solar panels on his roof, and they were incredibly expensive, and they didn’t work. And he was ripped off by one cowboy firm and then the other, and there was no grid connection and no storage. And it was kind of like a rich man’s hobby. It was like a cliché, the kind of rich hippie put solar panels on his roof.
And if you look at where solar has developed, solar is now the cheapest form of power generation that the world has ever known. So solar is now absolutely mainstream. You stop a random person on the street. If they have a pension or some kind of self-invested savings account or some such, the likelihood is that they’ll have some solar in their portfolio. It’s a mainstream infrastructure category.
And so can nature follow the same trajectory? I believe it can.
And so I think the transition we’re seeing now is a recognition, by those who are directly impacted by the degradation of nature and those who stand to benefit from the rebuilding of nature, of that nature and of the services that it provides. And I think a really obvious place to start our discussion is around flooding, natural flood management and drought, water storage, clean water, and so on. Because the links are so obvious and so easy to measure and to value between healthy ecosystems and the way water behaves, that is, I think, the most solid category of natural capital investing that is emerging.
Sanjeev Krishnan: Before going on the investment side, is this Thoreau and transcendentalism? Is it different? What inspires you about nature philosophically? And then I want to go from philosophy to sort of uncorrelated inflation hedges that perhaps could be the modern bond. But before we get there, let’s root ourselves a little bit in how you think about this because there are so many different ways to approach the philosophy of nature. And I’m curious about the roots for you.
Ben Goldsmith: I remember sitting next to a friend of my mother’s at a family Sunday lunch when I was a kid, and she said, “You’re Ben. You’re the one that loves nature.” And I remember thinking at the time, as a young boy, I remember thinking, “Yeah, I am.” But I knew somewhere, on some level, even if I didn’t say it, that my love of nature, my fascination with frogs and the blue eggs that I found in birds’ nests in spring and so on, that this wasn’t like stamp collecting. I knew on some level this wasn’t a hobby, that this was more of a kind of yearning or a calling. And I’ve always known that it wasn’t unique to me. Anyone who’s spent time with little people knows that they’re fascinated by nature, and that problems just evaporate when you open the door and get outside.
And similarly, we know that we have a visceral need for connection with nature. There’s amazing little pockets of data that are emerging. The Japanese health service has come up with the idea of forest bathing, and they’ve shown that if you go into the forest, the trees release compounds that lower your heart rate, that lower your blood pressure, that make you feel happy. And amazing experiments in California and Scandinavia around prisoners. If they’re given a few hours each week to get their hands in the soil and to grow their own potatoes and so on, they re-offend less, and they’re less violent, they’re less depressed. So we know we need nature in a visceral way, that we are fundamentally and intrinsically connected with nature.
But it took me a catastrophe in my life to really begin to think about these things and articulate these things. Because in 2019, in the farm that we are rewilding, where we bought a piece of knackered, low-productivity dairy farmland, and we are turning it back to nature and creating a wild place, in that place, my daughter Iris turned a vehicle on top of herself, in July 2019, and didn’t survive. It’s every parent’s worst nightmare. The darkness which envelops you when such a thing happens is beyond describing well in words. And what I found in the desperation of the days and weeks that followed that event, where I didn’t have a choice to go fetal and curl up in bed and not get up again. I have other kids, I have little kids, I have a young wife, I have family, I have my mother, God bless her, no longer with us, but my mother, people that need me. I was young. I was 39 when this happened. I could not disappear from this world. And yet I didn’t know how I would survive. And what I was struck by was the beauty of the world. I thought everything would be dark, and it wasn’t. I found myself looking at the world around me. There’s a little pond on the bend of a river, and, not so unlike Henry David Thoreau at Walden Pond outside Boston, I would go down there and sit for hours watching the dragonflies buzzing around after each other, and the innumerable patterns overlaid on patterns, and the sort of fascinating beauty of nature that summer. I would strip and swim in that pond. I would lie in the grass, and I felt relief from my desperation, just for a moment, each time. And this was where the shafts of light began to reappear in the darkness of my life, and where I began to rediscover a sense of hope and a sense of being able to go on again, was in nature.
And I realized that nature is the ultimate solace. It’s alive, and we are it, and it is us. And during that time, when I needed it most, I felt held. And I started to understand what my brother-in-law, who’s a devout Muslim, my brother-in-law’s Imran Khan, former prime minister of Pakistan, before that former captain of the Pakistan cricket team, a great legend of a man, and a man that I love very deeply and who’s been a huge inspiration to me, and a Sufi Muslim. And he used to see God in nature. It’s like a kind of manifestation of the divine, or a pathway to connect with the divine. He would say, “Thank God for the gift of fragrance,” and so on. And I started to understand what he meant by that during those very difficult weeks and months. And so you asked me what are the parallels between energy and decarbonization and these things, and now my total emphasis and focus on rebuilding nature. It’s because I’m doing something that I love deeply and that means the world to me, and that is really the only pathway for me to feel alive in a world that no longer has Iris in it. And so, yes, you talked about transcendentalism and Ralph Waldo Emerson and so on. Yeah, in the broadest possible sense, I find God in nature. And I find deep, deep meaning and solace and joy in nature.
And I think the Eastern traditions, for me, have been better at articulating how I feel than any other.
But these are very new ideas for me. And I don’t know that the kind of frantic searching for answers after the loss of my daughter brought me any closer to knowing what this all is. I surrender to a great mystery. What I know is I feel good when I’m in nature, and I want more of it. Since I was a kid, I refuse to accept the idea that Britain is not a place for wildlife. This is what we’ve been told. Britain is a place of order and tidiness and production, and we don’t have room for wildlife.
And I have letters in my drawer, when I was 11 years old, writing to the manager of Richmond Park, asking, “Why can’t we have wild boar in Richmond Park?” And very patient replies from the guy explaining why they’d frighten the horse riders and damage the grassland. But I would go to France and go to Spain, go to Italy, and experience real wildlife. And I thought, why can’t we have that here? And what I realized is that it’s my purpose to bring this back, working alongside many, many other people. I’m sitting right now in the David Attenborough Building in Cambridge, and it’s heaving with people who share the same mission as me. And I think a really useful thing to do is to fix the economics, to fix the incentives, such that it becomes critical infrastructure in investment terms, because that way we’ll fund this nature recovery that we want.
Sanjeev Krishnan: Well, it’s funny, I was always taught in financial services the value of any business, asset, et cetera, is its ability to generate cash flow and/or its scarcity value. And to me, nature and natural capital has that segmentation. Farmland, water (particularly depending on the price of water), timber, these are effectively emerging asset classes, some of them more mature. They produce cash flow. That cash flow tends to be uncorrelated to many other asset classes, and occasionally inflation-hedged. But the scarcity value aspect of it, particularly on the ecosystem side, I think is very immature. I always think about how we, as humans, have been very comfortable with fiat.
Gold is effectively a fiat commodity, right? We make it up. Recently crypto has become a fiat. Collective magical thinking just allows us to assign value. And one of the things I’ve been thinking about, particularly the last two or three years, particularly as more and more credible, established, successful investors, mainly from energy infrastructure, are peering into nature, there’s clearly farmland, there’s clearly timber, we can talk about, but what you’re talking about, in rewilding and wildlife, that is scarce. And how do we assign that fiat value that we’ve done as humans and as markets before?
Ben Goldsmith: So I think that there are a lot of people out there who feel the same way as we do in their heart, that they want nature back, they know something’s missing, they know that the landscapes of today would be unrecognizable to our grandparents’ or great-grandparents’ generation. And that’s true even of places like the US, where there’s still a lot of nature. In many ways, it’s a shadow of what it once was. And I think, therefore, that we have a cultural tailwind.
And polling shows this. The group More in Common here in Britain did some polling this year that showed that, overwhelmingly, people of all political colors, people of all backgrounds, rural, urban, old, young, rich, poor, they want nature back. They consider nature as fundamental to their sense of belonging and identity and well-being and so on. And so I think that the person sitting in the institutional investment firm looking at a nature investment proposal wants to write the check. They just need to be given a reason to do so.
So I think the culture comes first. We need to reconnect people spiritually and culturally with nature. And then, in a practical sense, how do you build the investment case for an institutional investor to write that check? How do you make it look like a bridge or a toll road or a solar asset or what have you? And I think there are a number of marketplaces that are starting to emerge which offer that potential. So if I may, I’d like to talk about natural flood management.
So there is a river that flows from Worcester to Oxford in England. It’s called the Evenlode. It’s a large tributary of the River Thames. And like most rivers in Great Britain and the Western world, it has been artificially straightened and canalized and disconnected from its floodplains. And the little marshy areas and the ponds have been drained. And everything is set up for productive agriculture right up to the edge of that watercourse, which means when it rains, it’s a fire hose. And the water barrels through that catchment at the rate of knots, trashing anything in its path. And of course, you then go a few weeks without rain and there is no water remaining. So the natural sponge effect of that landscape has been reversed, and you now have a highly destructive, highly volatile hydrology in that part of the country.
Well, there’s a railway line that runs from Worcester to Oxford as well that crosses the river 27 times. And that railway is one of the most flooded railways in Great Britain. It’s a nightmare for Network Rail, which is the national railroad operator, and for the train company that runs trains up and down the track. So a deal has been put together, comprised partly of public money but mostly of private capital, 150 million pounds so far of investment to re-wiggle and restore that Evenlode catchment, to restore the sponge. And 50 farmers have so far signed up to that catchment restoration program and are allowing the diggers onto their land to restore the meanders of the river and reconnect the river, so it can flood outwards into its floodplain following heavy rainfall, and to restore the wet, marshy areas and so on. I showed Fred yesterday at lunch some pictures from one industrial arable farmer, a guy who produces 15,000 tons of grain a year, eulogizing with great excitement about the diggers doing the work, as we speak, on his farm.
And the railroad company, which is called Network Rail, has committed to a multi-year resilience premium. So, in exchange for reduced frequency and intensity of flooding, they are paying a fixed premium, which contributes to the return of and the return on the capital that’s been invested by pension funds and other investors into the restoration of the river. And a supplementary resilience premium is now being paid by the city of Oxford itself, which no longer has to build concrete flood infrastructure to protect residents from flooding. And you have a bunch of other beneficiaries of this flood resilience program. There’s a couple of National Grid substations, there’s a Tesco’s food logistics hub, or what have you. And all of these will benefit from a river in which the water flows a lot more slowly.
And of course, the flip side of the coin is that the water company benefits as well, because the water will be more plentiful and will be there when they need it, because it’s flowing slower through the system, and will be cleaner, because if water flows slowly through a catchment, the ecosystem and the microbes and the plants and so on have more time to clean it of sedimentation and pollution and so on. So it’s kind of a big, big win, including for the farmers themselves, who have a new non-food-related income stream. And this is, I think, one of the big advantages of this idea of nature as infrastructure is that farming’s a volatile business. There are years in which you lose money, and there are years in which you make money. The weather, volatile food commodity markets, they’re obviously price takers, farmers, and so on. So if they can get a little income stream from natural flood management or some other nature infrastructure payments, then that can help support the resilience of their business and dampen the volatility of their annual economic performance. And so farmers are wildly excited about the possibilities of things like natural flood management.
Now, this is one of a suite of new market mechanisms that have grown up in my country, here in Britain. You have natural flood management, you have nutrient neutrality, which is a pollution mitigation market, which is linked to the fact that restored ecosystems eat up nitrates and phosphates and behave like kidneys in the landscape. That’s a service that is extremely useful for water companies that need clean water. It’s much cheaper and easier to prevent the pollution going into the water than it is to clean it using mechanical means. And so there’s a whole suite of things, carbon, biodiversity credits, and so on.
Sanjeev Krishnan: It reminds me, ten years ago, or twelve years ago, preventative health was seen as smoking cessation and BMI, and now you look at healthcare, it’s increasingly interested in preventative food as medicine, even mental health. It reminds you of, with the flood example, you’re getting people that are, from a systems level, benefiting and willing to finance the revenue model or the business model. Because it’s preventative ecosystem health that has real economic benefit that you can point to. Which is fantastic.
Ben Goldsmith: Well, that is the great challenge here, because there are projects everywhere that need funding. There are mangrove restorations in the tropics, and seagrasses and reefs, and there’s no shortage of NGOs and scientists and local governments and collectives and things that want to restore nature. There’s opportunities everywhere to rebuild healthy, functioning ecosystems. There’s also no shortage of capital.
And I believe that a lot of the managers of that capital want to invest in natural capital. A lot of them have even gone out and said to their stakeholders, “We’re going to invest in natural capital.” But when it comes to actually doing it, they struggle to find bankable projects, because the third component is the offtake. And that is the bottleneck. Who’s going to buy the services that these ecosystems create? And I think that the local opportunities are the ones that are most present in the here and now, where you have a flow of water through a landscape and you have people in that flow who are either flooding or running out of water, or both. And so regularizing and restoring the healthy functioning of catchments is a pretty neat way to demonstrate cost and benefit, and therefore to receive investment and produce an investment return.
But it’s by no means the only way, because most of the major companies in the world have a Paris alignment plan. They have some kind of net zero plan. Many of those companies have had a shareholder vote on that plan, and they can’t achieve it without carbon removals. Carbon removals, if we believe in the science of anthropogenic climate change, we are going to have to remove carbon from the atmosphere. And the cheapest and easiest way of doing that is through nature recovery. And so there is a market in voluntary nature-based carbon removals. And so I think, whilst that is more of a commodity market, that is a market that offers great potential for nature recovery.
Frédéric Michel: What’s great about the way you look at nature recovery is that you seem to see it as an entrepreneurial opportunity for farmers. What role do you see for governments in that new sort of way of treating that issue? Because they really haven’t done much in that regard over the last decades. And I mean, there is something in the UK, which is the BNG rule, right? Which is the biodiversity net gain rule, which at least is a mandatory compliance framework which can help. But I was wondering what your perception is of the role the government can play, because this is all led by private capital, in a way, capital initiative.
Ben Goldsmith: The best thing governments can do, especially rich-world governments, is get out of the way. Because the OECD governments hand out somewhere around seven hundred billion dollars a year in agricultural subsidies, which have a hugely distorting effect. You would not have highly destructive, unprofitable industrial sugar in the Everglades if it wasn’t for federal and state subsidies. You would not have British national parks stuffed to the rafters with sheep, which lose roughly 100 pounds per animal during their lifetime, if it wasn’t for subsidies.
Now, the EU dishes out somewhere in the region of 40% of its total budget through the Common Agricultural Policy. And they have a satellite, an eye in the sky, that looks at your land. And if the corners of your farm are being encroached by nature, if you have some nice scrub and berries, and where the birds are nesting, or you have a flooded area where the ducks and the frogs are coming in, a new wetland, the eye in the sky will mark that down, and that area will be removed from your subsidy calculation. So these subsidies create a perverse incentive to exclude nature, even from land which is not agriculturally productive.
And you can replicate the same in the sea. The world’s governments hand out somewhere around $30 to $40 billion in capacity payments to the fishing industry, even though there’s not enough fish. The last thing we need is more fishing boats with subsidized fuel. You wouldn’t have fishing on the high seas, it would not exist in a free market, if you didn’t have all these subsidies. So the best thing governments can do is to phase out and replace these destructive subsidies for industries which often have no grounding in rational economics. They’re not economically viable, and they need to get out of the way so that proper market signals start to come through about how we should use land. Because it’s not just food we need from the land. In fact, the least productive thirty percent of my country, Britain, produces less than two percent of the food, and yet it’s all farmed. If you fly from London up to Glasgow and look out the plane window, you’ll see nothing but agricultural sprawl. And yet the least productive thirty percent is not producing any food. But we need water, we need clean air, we need amenities, we need flood defense, we need all these other things from the land. And the market will pay for those things, but the subsidies need to get out of the way. So that’s what I’d have governments do, first and foremost.
Sanjeev Krishnan: I just think the political economics of that are so hard, and you know this better than me, Ben. You’ve been in governments and in politics. And I have a different theory of change. It’s not on the agenda, so I’m going to be hot-takey about this.
I think, if you think of what ’08, ’09 really inspired for me, was sort of the inability of policy and politics to really keep stability in the system. I mean, we would have a massive depression, in my opinion, if it wasn’t for the courage of central banks in 2008. I would argue they may have dislocated things in 2020, but they came together and coordinated, at least temporarily, and it may have caused some of the inflation that we’re still living with. But I wonder if there’s a central bank intervention here, just because I don’t have faith that you can get rid of those subsidies easily. But could we get a coalition of central banks and can we do something around natural capital and the value of quantitative nature easing, as opposed to quantitative easing? Now, it’s going to be controversial, but Article 6.2 and 6.4, now that it’s sort of progressed from Paris to actually have some more teeth, there’s still more teeth that we need. But I think there’s something there that I think could be explored.
Ben Goldsmith: Yeah, especially when you consider that the nations of the world came together in Montréal in 2021 and they signed the Kunming-Montréal Protocol, which pledged that each one would restore 30% of land and 30% of sea to a good state of nature by 2030. And in fact, that commitment is enshrined in law in the United Kingdom, in the Environment Act 2021, with a series of very tough ratcheting targets and a new Office for Environmental Protection to enforce the achievement of those targets.
So the political will ought to be there. I want to talk about England specifically, because for matters that relate to land and sea and nature, there is devolution in the United Kingdom. So Wales makes its own laws, Scotland, Northern Ireland, and England. And I was on the board of DEFRA, which principally has responsibility for policies in England. And I was on that board when Michael Gove was Secretary of State. He’s a Conservative lawmaker who was in the role under first Theresa May and then Prime Minister Boris Johnson. And he cares about nature, and he’s also a guy of heft and was able to get stuff done. He’s the one who passed the Environment Act of 2021. But he’s the one also who phased out agricultural subsidies in England following the Brexit vote. So we withdrew from the European Union, and therefore from its Common Agricultural Policy. And realizing that farmers need support, I think it was Warren Buffett who said it’s only when the tide goes out you can see who’s been swimming naked. Well, across vast swathes of Britain, farmers are not economically viable, especially in landscapes that are hopelessly not agriculturally productive. And so he designed a new scheme called the Environmental Land Management Scheme. And on the face of the bill, which I helped to write, the Agriculture Act 2021, we wrote “public money for public good.”
In other words the budget is still there. It’s roughly 2.5 billion pounds per year. It’s still there annually. The new Labour government has recommitted to it. But farmers now have to earn it. So if they want that public money, they have to demonstrate stewardship and restoration of the natural environment. And the more they do, the more public money they get. And in the wake of that great icebreaker ship, which is this Environmental Land Management Scheme, you’ve got a flotilla of new markets. We’ve discussed natural flood management, nutrient neutrality.
Biodiversity net gain, Frédéric mentioned, is modeled on US wetlands mitigation legislation. And the idea there is, when you want to build something, from a new church parking lot to a new highway or whatever it might be, national infrastructure down to a few houses, you have to deliver, by law, a net gain in biodiversity of at least 10%. In order to do that, you have to buy credits, nature credits, from someone who’s building a habitat bank. And so the market is known as BNG, biodiversity net gain, and there’s now a substantial market in biodiversity credits, which are being bought by housing developers and infrastructure developers and so on, and being sold by farmers.
So you get your small farmer in the uplands who’s got some economically non-viable sheep ranching business on 200 acres, and they now have a number of different revenue streams. They’re much more economically resilient than they ever were before. Because whilst their sheep business was never economic, they’re probably doing some kind of box scheme, and they’re still selling some lamb, or selling some beef, because cattle is a native animal and is conducive to ecological recovery, whereas sheep is the opposite. But they also might have some stewardship payments under the Environmental Land Management Scheme for good stewardship or restoration of their land. They might have a little habitat bank of 20 acres along the watercourse, or some such. They might be in some community or catchment-level natural flood management scheme, and suddenly they’ve got a whole bunch of different non-food-related revenue streams. So it could be potentially the key to keeping these very disadvantaged communities in these very remote places in situ, rather than Great Britain suffering the kind of rural depopulation that you find in parts of rural France, Italy, or in Spain. The España vaciada is a huge issue. So I think that socially it is doable, but we’ve got to get it right. It can’t be too bureaucratic, it’s got to be generous enough. And the government is making a bit of a ham fist of rolling this Environmental Land Management Scheme out, making it hard for farmers to access it.
Sanjeev Krishnan: For sure. Actually, we met a while ago, and I’m glad Fred put us back together, and would love to continue the conversation with you specifically on valuing nature. But as I’ve researched for this, and then talked to Fred, your exposure to the political spectrum reminds me more of a Rubik’s Cube than sort of a red, purple, blue, as an American would say. Talk to me about environmentalism and nature in the context of our politics, particularly where we are sitting today, with the wave of populism coming, and also just more complicated politics, just globally.
Ben Goldsmith: So at heart and when it comes to kind of non-nature, kind of broader environmental issues, I’m just a guy down the pub, like any of us. But at heart, I am a conservative in the British sense. So I believe in smallish government, and government doing what’s needed and not too much more than that. I believe in modest taxation. I want to encourage entrepreneurship, innovation. I want people to feel that they can keep the majority of the fruits of their labor. I believe in individual liberty. I guess you’d call me a kind of classical liberal or a small‑c conservative in that sense. And I am a deep nature lover, and I consider that to be integral, philosophically integral, to my conservatism, because I believe in good stewardship of that which matters to everyone, the kind of shared inheritance, the natural inheritance, heritage.
So I, as a conservative, think it’s very normal to be a conservationist. I don’t understand conservatives who don’t love nature. I just don’t think that is conservative in instinct. I think they’re more corporatists, or it’s not about conservatism, I think, to want to trash these beautiful things. I mean, the idea that bison in Montana, America’s national animal, the idea that they’re woke, they’re part of some kind of woke agenda, that’s nuts to me. What could be more American than American bison on the Great Plains? Just like, by the way, it’s not conservative to bung pork-barrel subsidy down the throats of sugar producers in the Everglades to keep them afloat in a market in which they would otherwise not survive. So I don’t believe in long-term subsidies for any industry. I believe in small government. I believe in loving nature. And I’m not alone. And Nixon was the most environmental president ever. He created the Clean Air Act…
Sanjeev Krishnan: Yeah. Started the EPA.
Ben Goldsmith: …the Clean Water Act. He said all American watercourses must be fishable, swimmable, drinkable. He created the EPA, the Endangered Species Act. And if you go back 80 or 90 years, Theodore Roosevelt, we call teddy bears teddy bears because of Theodore Roosevelt’s association with bears, and the protections for land and nature that he started dishing out. And it was Margaret Thatcher who’s the first world leader to stand at the UN and talk about the threat posed by global climate change.
So I think that conservatives do have a rich history on tackling some of these issues and on loving and standing up for nature. And I think that nature should be a kind of non-partisan issue. And when it becomes partisan, I’m highly suspicious of the motivations of those who make it so. So where do I think we are? I think somehow nature has been partially dragged into the culture wars.
But nevertheless, polling shows that people really care, and they want nature back. And the biggest issue is the breadth of support for nature. It’s kind of broad and shallow. And therefore, everyone wants it, but no one cares enough to make their vote about it until the issue starts to bite them locally. So I think the first environmental issue in my country that became an electoral issue was sewage in the rivers. It became a huge issue. And in the 2022 local elections, there were councils who got voted out because the rivers were full of crap.
And so I think, for voters to really make the leap and start voting on account of environmental issues, it has to hit them locally. But I think we’re moving into that space. Certainly big corporations are starting to understand the impact that nature has on their business, and not just because they’re being told to. Look at confectionery companies being constrained of supply of chocolate in West Africa because of deforestation and environmental breakdown. Look at manufacturing facilities that are being flooded with increasing intensity and frequency in northwestern Europe. Look at agricultural commodity companies being hit by increasingly volatile supply chains because of environmental degradation. And there’s the emergence of a new trend, which is insetting. Have you heard of this term, insetting?
Sanjeev Krishnan: Yes, yes, yeah.
Ben Goldsmith: This is the idea that if we’re going to buy nature-based carbon, we might as well buy it from projects which also beef up the resilience of our own supply chains. A good example would be Evian, which supplies bottled water. And they are investing heavily in nature recovery across the Evian landscape. It’s becoming one of the wildest and most beautiful parts of Europe because of investments made by the Evian water company. And those investments not only sequester carbon, but they also have a tremendously beneficial effect on the resilience of their supply chain, which is the water that they need. SABMiller did something similar with their brewing business in the forests around Bogotá. So I think this insetting idea is interesting.
Frédéric Michel: But if you take the UK example, do you see a way where there could be some common ground on nature restoration between the Greens and Reform, for example, the sort of new populist parties and then the traditional green movements? Or are they just disagreeing on anything from energy transition, climate target? Do you have hope that that area that you’re grabbing, nature restoration, which you see as core, could be maybe bringing some consensus a little bit?
Ben Goldsmith: So none of the political parties in this country are reflecting the broadly held views of the public on nature. There are no strongly pro-nature parties in the United Kingdom. The Green Party is not interested in nature at all. They had a new MP elected in a by-election not so long ago, and in her maiden speech, she didn’t use the term environment, nature, climate, conservation even once. None of those terms. All she spoke about was Gaza and left-wing culture wars issues. The Green Party has been entirely co-opted by a kind of hard-left, culture-wars, student-politics movement that has limited appeal, and that’s why they’re collapsing in the polls now. So it’s not a Green Party at all. It’s green in the sense of a watermelon. If you slice it open, it’s red on the inside. And at the other…
Frédéric Michel: So… yeah, what about the other end of the spectrum?
Ben Goldsmith: At the other end of the spectrum, the Reform Party will talk about the politics of rootedness and home. And there are certainly some people within the Reform Party who talk well of nature. Nigel Farage, as the leader, says that his happy place is fishing for sea bass, and he likes to forage for edible mushrooms and so on. But the reality so far, notwithstanding that the policies of Reform have not been made clear at all. It seems a little bit chaotic, they don’t seem to have a well-formed policy unit yet, we don’t really know what they’re going to do. But the rhetoric has been about defunding the nature agencies and removing obstacles to investment, growth, and profit. So they are absolutely not proposing anything particularly positive for nature.
And then the two larger parties, the Conservatives and the Labour Party, are broadly suggesting that they will stick with the policy reforms that were put in place by Michael Gove during the 2016 to 2020 period. And those reforms were good. They were a great leap forward for nature in our country, under a Conservative government. And it was really an element of luck that we had this heavyweight in DEFRA who cares about nature, who was well advised, and who was operating under two prime ministers, May and then Johnson, who really do care about this stuff, and there was the historic opportunity presented by Brexit to rethink a lot of these policies that relate to land and nature and so on. So hopefully the two larger parties will stick with what was done, even if their heart is not really in it.
So the good news, therefore, is the policy framework looks better now than it did pre-2016, and the public want more nature. The bad news is that there’s no politicians taking this really seriously.
Sanjeev Krishnan: I want to link, just toward the end, something that… I’m an Anglophile, went to university in the UK, love the UK. When Brexit occurred, I always thought, just regardless of whether you’re Remain or Leave, that it would become a laboratory for deploying innovation, particularly in sort of nature-positive innovation in agriculture, as an example. To your point there’s so many great technologies of nitrogen use efficiency, or micronutrients, or even biocontrol. But the regulatory cycle is so long, particularly in Brussels, that even though they regulate it out, the replacement isn’t approved for years. And, I mean, Ben, you know this, any startup can’t survive that.
What is your belief? Could the UK serve as a bit of a laboratory to deploy nature-positive innovation in a way that it doesn’t have the friction of Brussels, and perhaps could be a bit of a laboratory for Europe, and maybe even for the US, frankly?
Ben Goldsmith: Yeah, I mean, I’d say the US has been something of an inspiration to the UK. The wetlands banking legislation has been hugely effective, and there’s a load of mitigation markets related to the Endangered Species Act and Clean Water Act and so on, the cleanup of Chesapeake Bay, that have led to tremendous tracts of land and wetland and coast being restored. So the US has a pretty well-functioning set of mechanisms for nature recovery. And some of the things that we’re developing in the United Kingdom have drawn inspiration from those mechanisms. But yes, we don’t manufacture stuff like we used to.
We’re good at exporting ideas. And so I think a lot of countries are watching the rollout of our Environmental Land Management Scheme, which is kind of a world first. The only country that has anything similar is Costa Rica, which went from 20% forest cover to 60% forest cover in one generation, because they created a set of incentives, publicly funded incentives for restoration of forest. We are really the first rich-world nation to do something along those lines. And in the wake of that policy, we have these new innovations taking place around water and pollution and carbon and biodiversity offsets and so on. And I think if we get them right, they will be replicated. The French government is already looking at replicating our BNG scheme in France, for example. So, yeah, I’m optimistic that we can be a really useful laboratory.
And you couldn’t pick a better laboratory, because the Industrial Revolution started in Britain. We were the first country systematically to set about dismantling our nature, such that we are in the bottom 10% of countries of the world as far as nature depletion goes. If we can be the first country to show how you rebuild it, how you create the mechanisms within which you can rebuild nature, then I think we’ll have done something really useful on the global stage. But I do agree with you as far as bureaucracy, and we’re absolutely not immune in the UK. It’s worse in Europe, but things are very, very slow to get agreed and to get approved and so on. And that is holding back a whole bunch of different sectors. For example, it’s holding farmers back. Farmers and nature conservationists are much closer than you think. The culture wars would have us believe that they hate each other, but in fact, it’s not true. Farmers and nature lovers are…
Sanjeev Krishnan: Nope. Even in the US, by the way.
Ben Goldsmith: Yeah, so we’re much closer to each other than one might think, and yet farmers are held back by bureaucracy, and they’re endlessly harassed by government. Look at the trouble we have reintroducing missing species. Every single beaver, European beaver, that exists in Britain today is there because of unlicensed releases, so-called beaver bombers, who got fed up after four or five decades of trying to persuade government to allow them to reintroduce the Eurasian beaver, a native keystone species, into our watercourses. Eventually they just got on and did it, by night, at the back of vans.
And so this is illustrative of a government that simply cannot come to a decision on approving things that are a little bit out of the box. And I think we’re lucky that nature gets on with it anyway, because nature recovery in Europe has been quite amazing during our lifetimes. There were 1,000 or so wolves in 1990 in Europe. There’s now 27,000. There are 25,000 bears. The lynx is recovering. There are lynx in the Jura in France. The beavers are back in the millions now, across European countries from which they were totally extirpated several centuries ago. So nature is recovering. We’ve added vast amounts of wild forest during the last two or three decades, partly because of land abandonment. Nature will jump at any opportunity to recover. It’s an unrelenting living organism that yearns for itself. And so the recovery of nature just unfolds constantly.
So this is not an expensive problem to fix. We just tweak the incentives. It will happen. There are much more costly and complicated problems to solve than nature. We can do this. We just need to get the right incentives in place. And the incentives are downstream from culture. And I think we’re undergoing a great cultural moment around nature and connection. And so I’m broadly optimistic that we’re going to see it happen in our lifetimes.
Frédéric Michel: I think we’ll use another episode for you to tell us about your programs of reintroducing beavers in the southwest of France, which I find absolutely fascinating. Thanks so much for the optimistic nature of this conversation. Really, we’re leaving with a lot of optimism about what we can do on nature with you, Ben. So I’m really grateful for the time we had together. It’s been great.
Sanjeev Krishnan: Ben, thank you again so much.
Ben Goldsmith: Thank you so much, Frédéric. Thank you, Sanjeev. It was a great pleasure speaking to you. I’m a big fan of S2G, and I’m a friend and a fan of Lucas, and of all of you.
Tonya Bakritzes: Thank you for tuning into the S2G podcast. If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, leave us a review, or share it with a friend. For more information or to connect with us, check out s2ginvestments.com.
Thank you for tuning into the S2G podcast. If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, leave us a review, or share it with a friend. For more information or to connect with us, check out s2ginvestments.com.
This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal, business, tax, or investment advice, nor should it be used to evaluate any investment or security. It is not directed at, or intended for, any current or prospective investor in any investment vehicle sponsored by S2G. Investing involves risk, including the potential loss of capital.
References to specific companies are for illustrative and educational purposes only and do not represent an endorsement or investment recommendation.
The views expressed by podcast guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of S2G. For additional important information, please visit: s2ginvestments.com/disclosures.